Tuesday 1 September 2009

Better the second time around?

Well after a month off, we're back and more indie than ever I suppose.

In The Times newspaper, in which the music reviewers attempted to be "hip" and "with it" in discussing The Horrors new album, they raised an interesting and valid question... How many times has a band's second album better than their first?



Sure, there have been great examples of bands crashing and burning. The more commercial the band, usually the worse they do. There's a ton of bands today, that are favorites of the critics, that aren't going to make an album as well received as their first. And it'll be compared to their first, and they'll be assumed to have lost, whatever it is they had. This is the doom I foresee for bands like MGMT.

The more subtle version of this is when a second album is despised by critics but then goes on to be well received by fans and eventually by critics many, many years later. Good examples of this are Weezer's Pinkerton and BRMC's "Take Them On, On Your Own". Taking this to it's logical conclusion, you get Elbow, who's first album, though not hated by critics, went mostly unnoticed, then 14 years later they come up with The Seldom Seen Kid.

So, what bands do you know who out did themselves the second time around?

Oh, and today's photo is from Jurriaan Persyn, who's a bit of a jazz enthusiast it would seem. And according to last month's poll, radio is dead. I'll go tell those pesky radio presenters to pack it in finally.

No comments: